At the end of October 2026, the Tarrytown School District had 10 single-family houses for sale. In the same month it had 53 condos and co-ops on the market, plus 7 multi-family buildings. Those are the inventory figures in William Pitt Sotheby's October 2026 Tarrytown market report, which covers the district shared by Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow. A year earlier the count was 18 houses and 41 condos and co-ops.
So in twelve months, the number of houses for sale almost halved and the number of condos and co-ops rose by about 29%. In October, a buyer touring the district saw roughly five attached listings for every detached one. That ratio says more about how a Tarrytown purchase will go than the village median does. A family looking for a house and a buyer looking for a two-bedroom near the river are in the same village and the same school district, but they are bargaining under different conditions.
Where the 53 Listings Live
Tarrytown's condo and co-op supply comes mostly from a few large communities, and a buyer can name most of them.
Hudson Harbor sits on the Tarrytown waterfront and currently has 218 units, according to The Hudson Independent's August 2026 report on the site's next building. Edgemont at Tarrytown is larger still by unit count. Its condo association describes 188 units in 34 buildings on 26 acres, within a mile of the Hudson and close to road and rail. The Quay of Tarrytown is a condominium complex on South Broadway near the foot of the Mario M. Cuomo Bridge.
Some of the district's attached supply is across the line in Sleepy Hollow, at Edge-on-Hudson, the redevelopment of the former GM plant site. Its Daymark condo building has 100 units and was more than 90% sold as of March 2026. The same developer update put the townhomes at One Kingsland at sold out for Phase 1 and nearly sold out for Phase 2. Because a district-level report counts both villages, a buyer comparing condos in Tarrytown is also comparing them with the newest waterfront product in Sleepy Hollow.
Single-family houses have no equivalent. A house comes to market one at a time, when a family decides to sell. No developer has a building's worth of them to release.
Westchester Shows the Same Split, and Prices It
Village-level samples are small, so the clearest evidence of how each market prices comes from countywide data. For the 12 months through October 2026, the OneKey MLS Local Market Update for Westchester County shows single-family homes selling at 104.4% of their original list price. Condos sold at 100.0% and co-ops at 99.0%.
Inventory moved in different directions over the same 12 months. Single-family inventory fell 2.4%, from 872 to 851. Condo inventory rose 3.6%, from 278 to 288. Co-op inventory rose 12.9%, from 434 to 490. The rolling 12-month median sale prices through October were $1,065,000 for single-family homes, $560,000 for condos and $240,000 for co-ops.
Take those percentages back to Tarrytown. On a $1 million house, the four-point gap between the county's single-family and condo sale-to-list ratios is about $40,000 above asking that a condo buyer would not usually pay. Tarrytown's inventory gap is far wider than the county's. Houses in the district fell from 18 listings to 10 while the county's single-family supply dipped by only a few percent, so the pressure on Tarrytown house buyers is likely stronger than the county average shows.
For a buyer, the point is practical. In the house market, list price is often where negotiation starts going up. In the condo and co-op market, list price is closer to where the deal actually ends. The OneKey quarterly report for Q3 2026 shows prices rising in both markets: the countywide single-family median rose 10.0% to $1,189,000 and the condo median rose 17.1% to $615,000 compared with Q3 2025. Condos are not losing value. Their buyers simply have more choices when they write an offer.
One October House Sale Is Not a Trend
The same William Pitt report shows the district's October single-family sales as one home: $600,000, 86% of asking, 141 days on market, $272 per square foot. That one sale describes one property. It does not show houses softening, and it should not suggest that Tarrytown sellers have started taking 86 cents on the dollar. We made the same point in an earlier post on what Tarrytown's median price actually measures: with this few monthly sales, a single closing can swing the median in either direction.
The year-to-date count says more. The district recorded 32 single-family sales through October 2026, against 40 through October 2025. The October listing count was 10 houses, against 18 in October 2025, so the lower sales count comes alongside a much thinner selection.
The Pipeline Adds Attached Homes, Not Houses
At Hudson Harbor, RMA Development has proposed The Gatehouse on Hudson View Way and Division Street. It is a four-story building of about 100,000 square feet with 81 units: 10 studios, 29 one-bedrooms and 42 two-bedrooms. The Hudson Independent reported that at the Planning Board's August 24 meeting the developer said it would prefer 130 parking spaces rather than the 203 on the plans. The project still needs a parking variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals, and planning staff were reviewing a supplemental environmental impact statement. An earlier version of the plan had 21 three-bedroom units. The current mix has nothing larger than a two-bedroom.
On South Broadway, the 303 South Broadway site beside The Quay drew a 2025 proposal for up to 320 rental units and 4,700 square feet of retail. Rentals are not for sale, but a large new rental building competes for the same first-time buyer who might otherwise purchase a one-bedroom condo nearby.
At Edge-on-Hudson, the developer reported in March 2026 that 587 of a planned 1,177 certificates of occupancy had been issued. Its homes are condos, townhomes and apartments, so the half still to come adds to the attached side of the district's supply.
None of these projects adds a detached house. For a family set on a yard and a driveway, the supply in this district depends on existing owners deciding to sell.
How the Split Plays Out for Each Kind of Client
| If you are... | What the late-2026 numbers point to |
|---|---|
| Buying a single-family house | Ten listings in the district in October, and countywide houses selling above original list over the past 12 months. Expect competition, and decide your ceiling before you tour. |
| Buying a condo or co-op | More than fifty listings in the district in October, and countywide sales at or just under list. You have time to compare buildings and room to negotiate terms. |
| Selling a house | Scarcity works for you. With so few houses for sale, a well-prepared house has little direct competition. |
| Selling a condo or co-op | Your buyer can compare your unit with other units in your complex, with buildings across the village and with new construction at Edge-on-Hudson. Price and presentation have to win that comparison. |
The last row deserves attention from owners at Hudson Harbor, Edgemont and The Quay. A unit in a large complex is often listed alongside a nearly identical unit in the same complex, so the buyer's decision comes down to condition, light, floor and price. Strategy for an attached-unit sale in Tarrytown starts with that side-by-side comparison, not with the village median.
Questions Buyers Ask About This Split
Does the Tarrytown School District report include Sleepy Hollow? Yes. The William Pitt report is organized by the Tarrytown School District, which covers both villages, so its condo and co-op count includes buildings such as The Daymark at Edge-on-Hudson. If you want to compare the two villages in other ways, our post on why Sleepy Hollow and Tarrytown tax bills differ covers that side.
Will The Gatehouse add condos or rentals? Local coverage has described its units both ways. The Hudson Independent's November 2025 article called them condominiums, and its August 2026 update called them apartments. As of the August meeting, the project was still in Planning Board review.
Is a condo a stepping stone to a house in Tarrytown? It can be. The figures show two different paces, though. A condo purchase here moves at the buyer's speed, and the later move to a house will move at the speed of single-family inventory. Families planning that sequence do better when they line up the sale of the condo with the timing of the house search, a topic covered in our guide to buying and selling at the same time.
If you own a Tarrytown house or condo and want to know which of these two markets your home is really competing in, Land O Listings will prepare a valuation built on the current listings in your segment, not on a village-wide median. Request a Free Home Valuation, or browse current Tarrytown homes for sale to see the split for yourself.